*This article is not medical advice. Before starting on any health related regimen, seek the advice of your Primary Care Physician or an M.D.
Perhaps one of the more important molecules involved in the Mitochondrial Electron Transport Chain, Creatine Production, Phosphatidyl Choline Production, Lactic Acid Build Up, Thyroid Issues, and Mast Cell / Histamine Dominant Cases…..And A Necessity To Evaluate Prior To NAD Supplementation
Most people get their homocysteine checked, and conclude, oh, my homocysteine is pretty normal, my ‘methylation’ is just fine. Not so fast.
Folks with low SAMe can suffer from :
Unrelenting Fatigue / PEM
Build up of lactic acid upon exertion
Poor Catecholamine clearance (sensitive to quercetin, etc)
Poor histamine clearance
Sensitive to alcohols
Respond well to creatine (loose stools aside)
Negative reaction to NAD IV’s or NAD precursors
Poor circulation (cold hands and feet)
Poor thyroid function
Low anti oxidant defenses against hydrogen peroxide and lipid peroxidation
This blog article, is meant to be a descriptive article on the compound, SAMe, produced in the methionine part of the methylation cycle primarily. Most people in the world of chronic illness, have heard of SAMe, but most steer clear. It has a pretty polarized reputation in terms of negative responses. And before you try it, it is worthwhile exploring both your genetics and physiology to see if it is a potential fit.
What is SAMe ?
Well, SAMe, stands for (S-adenosylmethionine) and is produced primarily in the methioneine part of the methylation cycle. Methionine is converted into SAMe by the gene MAT1a primarily, and to a secondary degree, by MAT2a. MAT1a and MAT2s require ATP as a cofactor. This is just another example, why for some, the production and conservation (pacing) of ATP is critical – not to go pump iron at the gym or do a 5 mile run, but to enable our physiology to run in a normalized way – without ATP, many many systems shut down.
MAT1a is different from MAT2a in that it has a cysteine residue, that is highly sensitive to oxidative and nitrative stress (S-Nitrosylation by excess aberrant nitric oxide, think our friend NOS2 again). MAT1a is primarily expressed in the adult liver, while MAT2a is primarily expressed in the fetal or replicating/repairing/or developing liver. Interesting. MAT1a and MAT2a produce both SAMe and pyrophosphate and inorganic phosphate. Interesting that the “P” in ATP is a phosphate group. Magnesiunm coordinates the ATP phosphate groups, and potassium helps organize the catalytic site. Methione and ATP are the substrates for MAT1a, and MAT2a. NADP+ binds the regulatory protein MATbeta, and glutathione, ADH5, and thioredoxin systems help protect the cysteine residue. We will get to cysteine production and delivery later😊.
Did I Say SAMe Production Can Be Inhibited By Oxidative Stress ?
Yes, yes I did. MAT1a has a cysteine residue that is sensitive to degradation. In particular, sensitive to high levels of nitric oxide radicals (nitrative stress - think nitrotyrosine, nitroguanosine, nitroguanine, peroxynitrite), often produced in NOS Uncoupling (high ADMA, SDMA), and upregulated NOS2 cases. There is a genetic mutation on NOS2 that upregulates it 473%, and is the primary reason I ask clients to consider the 23andme genetic test, it is that important. ADH5 and the Thioredoxin systems are the ones that step in to protect cysteine residues from a process called S-Nitrosylation. Cysteine residues are delivered enzymatically by the CBS/CTH part of the transulfuration pathway.
When Genetics Suggest An Investigation Is Definitely Worthwhile
When I see compromise on MAT1a, NOS2 Upregulations, ADH5 compromise, and CBS downregulations - this creates a bit of a perfect storm for low SAMe (low cysteine availability, excess nitric oxide, lowered protection of cysteine residues, and lower function of MAT1a to begin with). Hydroxyl radical produced from the combination of hydrogen peroxide and unbound iron also can inhibit MAT1a.
Why Do We Need SAMe ?
Below are some of the systems that use SAMe as a cofactor:
· Phosphatidyl Choline Production – major consumer of SAMe: SAMe is a cofactor for the gene PEMT, and phosphatidyl choline is used in bile production, and in cell membranes amongst other things. Higher oxidative stress that creates lipid peroxidation will increase the need for phosphatidyl choline, as will detoxification regimens. PEMT uses 3 SAMe molecules for every molecule of Phosphatidyl Choline produced.
· Creatine – major consumer of SAMe: SAMe is the cofactor for the gene GAMT in creating creatine. Ever know somebody that responded strongly to Creatine ? GAMT uses one molecule of SAMe for every molecule of creatine produced.
NNMT: methylates nicotinamide, routing that fraction away from NAD+ salvage. NAM is produced in metabolizing all NAD precursors, and SAMe is required to clear it. Excess NAM inhibits PDH, the entry to the krebs cycle. Ever know somebody who had a very negative reaction to high dose or IV NAD precursors? Before restoring NAD+ levels, SAMe is the first thing to check. Clinics that administer NAD IV’s without checking SAMe and or NAM are risking significant negative reactions in their patients.
o The metabolism of NAM via SAMe creates the metabolite 1-MNA, which is used to stimulate SIRT1, which is a key gene in activating NOS3. Ever know somebody who has issues with NOS3 such as circulation, blood pooling, and cold hands and feet that also has histamine/mast cell issues, and build up of lactic acid upon exertion ?·
SAMe also supplies methyl groups for DNA, RNA, proteins, lipids, and also feeds polyamine synthesis. Ever know somebody who is sensitive to “amines”?
CoQ10 – SAMe is a cofactor in coq10 bio synthesis – uh oh. Specifically, in the CoQ3, and CoQ5 genes.
· GNMT : methylates glycine to sarcosine, helps buffer the SAMe pool and is maor route of methyl group turnover.
· COMT: methylates catechols, including catecholamines, and some of their metabolites. Ever know somebody who is sensitive to COMT inhibitors ? It could be both low SAMe and some COMT inhibition genetically.
· PNMT: methylates norepinephrine to make epinephrine
· HNMT: methylates intracelular histamine. Anybody with mast cell and histamine issues should automatically be suspicious of low SAMe, low B2, low NADPH, low magnesium given how histamine is metabolized.
· ASMT: methylates N-acetylserotonin to make melatonin.
· TPMT: methylates thiopurine drugs.
· AS3MT: methylates arsenic. I once had a client who enormous arsenic levels, just sitting on a arsenic treated hand made chair/bench all day as a receptionist. Arsenic is ubiquitous in ground water, and rice.
· DNMT1, DNMT3a, DNMT3B: methylates existing and new DNA methylation patterns during replication.
· EZN1, EZH2, SETD2, EHMT1, EHMT2, DOT1L, PRMT1, PRMT5: methylate particular lysines and argines on histones. Helps regulate transcription chromatin structure, and RNA processing.
· METTL3, METTL16, NSUN2, TRDMT1, FBL, RNMT, CMTR1, CMTR2: these genes install methyl marks on mRNA, tRNA, rRNA, or the mRNA cap.
Mitochondrial dependence on SAM-e
Most folks know and appreciate that mitochondria need CoQ10 to facilitate electron flow between the various electron transport complexes. COQ3 and COQ5 both use SAMe in the production of COQ10.
Lesser known, is that SAMe is needed in the assembly of mitochondrial electron transport chain complex I: NDUFAF7. NUDUFAF7 is technically a factor gene in helping assemble other complex I genes – namely NDUFS2. NUDFAF5 does the same thing for NDUFAS7. When I see genetic compromise on NDUFS2, or NDUFS7 along with compromises in their ability to produce SAMe – these folks often have the hallmarks of a classic Mito ETC 1 block (lactic acid, high NADH, negative responses to krebs cycle cofactors – B1, etc). That is a clue to definitely assess SAMe status.
LIAS (Lipoic Acid Synthsis): uses SAM chemistry and iron sulfur clusters to insert sulfur atoms during lipoate synthesis (Lipoic acid synthesis). Protein bound lipoate is then required by several key genes - so without SAMe - these genes wont be able to get Lipoic Acid:
PDH - entry point of krebs cycle - build up of lactic acid results
DLST - Alpha Keto Glutarate Production will be low - low AKG, poor krebs cycle function
GCLS (Glycine Cleavage System) - cant cleave and clear glycine, high urinary glycine anybody ?
DLAT: Metabolism of BCAA’s (Iso Leucine, Leucin, Valine)
Mitochondrial Ribosomes and tRNA’s : TFB1M, NSUN4, METTL15, MRM1/2/3, TRMT5, TRMT10C, TRMT61B, CDK5RAP1. These genes modify rRNA and tRNA supporting mitochondrial protein synthesis. CDK5RAP1 uses radical SAM chemistry for a tRNA methylthiolation reaction.
Citrate Synthase (CS in Krebs Cycle) and Electron Transfer flavoprotein (think B2) modification (METTL12, ETFBKMT): METTL12 methylates Citrate Synthase in the krebs cycle. ETFBKMT, methylates the ETF beta sub unit , and SAMe is used by both.
CBS (transulfuration pathway)
Yes, CBS. CBS creates cystathioneine and then cysteine is created by the CTH gene. When I see downregulations on CBS, this spells trouble when not addressed – because intracellular enzymatic delivery of cysteine is one of the most important processes in the body for : iron sulfur clusters (mito function), heme (mito, detox, nitric oxide, etc), and immune function (zinc fingers control the immune system and almost all uses zinc cysteine clusters). Blood serum levels of cysteine are not sufficient here, low cystathioneine levels are the clue when genetic downregulations of CBS are present. What stimulates a downregulated CBS gene ? SAMe😊.
MTHFR
Senses SAMe and SAMe can inhibit MTHFR, reducing the production of 5-methylfolate for homocysteine re-methylation.
AMD1, SRM, SMS (Polyamine Synthesis)
AMD1 converts SAMe to decarboxylated SAMe. SRM and SMS use that derivative as an aminopropyl donor to produce Spermidine and spermine respectively. Ever hear of spermidine in longevity circles ? Ever hear of somebody that responded really well to it 😊?
MOCS1, CDKAL1, ELP3, TYW1 – all use radical SAM reactions.
The MOCS1a product pariticipates in molybdenum cofactor synthesis (hello MOCO steal group😊). CDKAL1, ELP3, and TYW1 use radical SAM chemistry in distinct tRNA modification pathways. This chemistry uses iron sulfur clusters (which need cysteine) to cleave SAMe and initiate the reaction.
SAMe is also used as a Nutrient Sensor !
SAMTOR and mTORC1 – are involved in growth signaling. When methionine deprivation lowers intracellular SAMe, SAMTOR binds GATOR1, which restrains the Rag signaling needed to bring mTORC1 to the lysosome. When SAMe rises , it binds SAMTOR directly and releases the brake. This lets methionine availability, contribute to mTORC1 activity alongside other nutrient and growth signals.
METTL16 and MAT2a – restoring SAMe supply. When SAMe is scarce, METTL16 spends longer bound to a stem-loop in MAT2a RNA. This favors, splicing of a retained intron, increasing mature MAT2a mRNA and helping make the cell make more of the enzyme that synthesizes SAMe.
CBS and MTHFR: higher SAMe activates CBS and inhibits MTHFR. Together these effects favor routing homocysteine towards cystathionine and transulfuration while reducing the drive to recycle it back to methionine.
SAMe is used in the metabolism and delivery of Selenium (think thryoid, anti oxidant systems)
Dietary selenium converges in a pool of selenide, and SEPHS2 uses selenide and ATP to make selenophosphate and SEPSECS turns that selenophosphate to make selenocysteine directly on the dedicate tRNA. Hint - see cysteine again here:).
All the thyroid DIO1, DIO2, DIO3 (Deiodinases) require selenocysteine, through the core selenocysteine insertion machinery. Look for impaired T4 to T3 conversion.
Selenocysteine gets inserted into proteins: FTSJ1 uses SAMe to methylate ribose on selenocysteine tRNA, and this helps the ribosome insert selenocysteine at select UGA codons, in particular for GPX1, and GPX3. This insertion process effects GPX1 (ubiquitous intracellular glutathione peroxidase) and GPX3 (extracellular glutathione peroxidase) quite significantly, but does not appear to be needed by Mito based GPX4, Olfactory GPX6, and Endo Reticulum based GPX7, and GPX8, or the epithelial based GPX2. GPX7, 8, and 5 all use catalytic cysteine residues, not selenocysteine.
TPMT and INMT use SAMe dependent methylation to produce trimethylate-seleninium, a urinary selenium metabolite.
Symptoms Consistent With SAMe Deficiency
I am not a big fan of using symptomology as a guide post for treatment – symptoms are too general usually to infer something specific. But they can be used to explain and reinforce what the genetics point towards and the right labs validate what is happening.
What would we expect if somebody was low in SAMe:
· Cant clear catecholamines (sensitive to quercetin, etc), high dopamine, etc
· Cant clear histamine (mast cell / histamine issues)
· Fatigue (poor mitochondrial electron transport chain function – block at complex i) and build up of lactic acid upon exertion
· Low production of creatine – and thus ATP – fatigue
· Low production of phosphatidyl choline – poor cell membrane integrity (these folks are reactive and sensitive), and poor bile flow / fat digestion, and this susceptible to SIBO.
· Low cysteine availability enzymatically – low immune function (zinc fingers), low availability of iron sulfur clusters (low mito function in both the ETC, and krebs cycle)
· Low heme availability – which needs both cysteine availability and iron sulfur clusters. Poor phase 1 detox, low catalase (high uncleared hydrogen peroxides), poor metabolism of tryptophan, poor circulation and blood flow (NOS enzymes need heme).
· Low Coq10 availability – potentially using COQ10 supplementation as a crutch.
Potential Contraindications of SAM-e?
· Potential sleep contraindications
· Astrocyte histamine clearance. If HNMT was limited by low SAMe, restoring SAMe can help clear histamine and in the process disturb sleep. Histamine released by neurons helps sustain wakefulness, and the transporters OCT3 and PMAT take up extracellular histamine. So it’s the release and transport of ‘stuck’ histamine and its clearance that can disturb sleep.
· PRMT5 uses SAMe to methylate arginine 3 on histone H4, potentially linking sleep, glial biology, and methylation.
· Low functioning MTHFR and or low 5-methylfolate availability, can make some susceptible to reactions with SAMe, because SAMe can provide feedback to slow MTHFR. B9, B12 status important here,
o MTR (Methyl B12 is cofactor) regenerates methionine. Zinc activates homocysteine for methyl transfer.
o MTRR (FAD/FMN/B2, and NADPH are cofactors) reactivates MTR when its bound B12 becomes oxidized.
o In B12 deficiency, reduced MTR activity can also leave folate disproportionately in the 5-MTHF form and impair regeneration of THF, this is often described as the methyl-folate trap, and it can coexist with low SAMe.
Testing
Doctors Data Methylation Profile (Blood Draw, $180ish) will provide: SAMe, SAH, Cysteine, Cystathioneine, Methionine, Homocysteine.
US Biotek NAD Profile (Finger prick, $140ish) will provide plasma levels of : NAD+, NADH, NADPH, NADP, NAM, NA.
That is it for now! This a draft I will continue to refine, and add in references for your perusal.
References:
[1] Coming soon:)